I read it, and I don't know where it implies you know anything about states of matter or material physics.
I also read the response, and it seems to be more general than you give credit. Allow me to interpret. "You probably shouldn't have strong opinions on things you don't have a strong expertise in."
Duh, it implies I don't know about magnetism, which is something I stated.
What it tries to do is to provoke me to impostor my way into searching about magnetism and then repeating something that I read. And it failed at that. I'm not here to display any prowess in physics knowledge.
I also read the response, and it seems to be more general than you give credit. Allow me to interpret. "You probably shouldn't have strong opinions on things you don't have a strong expertise in."